Sunday, January 30, 2011

Mailbox Monday

Mailbox Monday was created by Marcia at The Printed Page. MM is currently on tour and is being hosted by Rose City Reader for the month of January.

This week I took my son to 2 libraries and stopped at 1 Goodwill and I found some awesome bargains on books!

From PBS:
  • Secrets of the Tudor Court: Between Two Queens by Kate Emerson


From the Goodwill:
  • Shadow Princess by Indu Sundaresen
  • The Scarlet Contessa by Jeanne Kalogridis
  • Now Face to Face by Karleen Koen


From Cheapstacks Used Bookstore in the Grand Haven Library:
  • Queen of Swords by Judith Tarr
  • A Northern Light by Jennifer Donnelly


From the For Sale section of the Norton Shores Library:
  • The Road by Cormac McCarthy
  • No Country for Old Men by Cormac McCarthy


Grand total for this shopping spree: $7.20! Hope everyone else had some fabulous finds this week!

Suddenly Sunday

Suddenly Sunday is hosted by Svea at A Muse in the Fog.

Hope everyone has had a fabulous weekend. It is still frigid here in Michigan so once again I stayed indoors all weekend. Unfortunately, due to some work related turmoil, I didn't get any reviews posted for this week. I did get some reading done though so coming up this week are reviews for:
  • Here be Dragons by Sharon Kay Penman
and
  • The Secret Scripture by Sebastian Barry
I am about 1/3 of the way through City of Dreams by Beverly Swerling and liking it so far.

This weekend I took the time to reorganize and weed through my bookshelves. That took me the better part of yesterday evening. I also hit the sale section of the library, the used bookstore in another library and 1 Goodwill and had some fantastic finds. I have come to realize I love the thrill of the "hunt" as much as I like the reading.

Also wanted to mention that there are a ton of great giveaways going on around the blogosphere. Here are a the ones I've seen in case anyone is interested:

Giveaway of a Dear America Diary Set @ The Maidens Court (ends 2/9)
Follower Giveaway of The Loves of Charles II by Jean Plaidy @ Passages to the Past (ends 2/9)
Giveway of the Tudor Secret by C.W. Gortner @ Passages to the Past (ends 2/5)
Giveaway of To Serve a King by Donna Russo Morin @ Passages to the Past (ends 2/5)
Giveaway of By Fire, By Water by Mitchell James Kaplan @ All Things Historical Fiction (ends 2/5)
Giveaway of The Arrow Chest by Robert Parry @ All Things Historical Fiction (ends 2/10)
Giveway of The Princess of Nowhere by Prince Lorenzo Borghese @ Muse in the Fog (ends 2/20)

Up for Grabs at Goodreads:
Instruments of Darkness by Imogen Robertson (ends 2/9)
Elizabeth I by Margaret George (ends 2/25)
All the Queen's Players by Jane Feather (ends 2/28)
Crestmont by Holly Weiss (ends 2/22)
Bloodroot by Amy Greene (ends 1/31)
Parrot & Olivier in America by Peter Carey (ends 1/31)
The Second Duchess by Elizabeth Loupas (end 2/20)
The Land of Painted Caves by Jean M. Auel (ends 1/31)

So many great books... so little time!

Thursday, January 27, 2011

Random Musings-Series Taken Over by Other Authors

So recently there has been a lot of buzz over whether there will be a 4th book in Stieg Larsson's Millenium trilogy. I recently read on New Dork Review of Books of rumors being confirmed that Larsson's partner, Eva Gabrielsson, plans to finish the fourth novel he was working on when he died. It got me thinking-are series better when they are taken over by other authors? It makes me wonder if someone else who didn't originally conceive of the idea could bring the same kind of magic to a series as the original author.

I confess I have my doubts. I think back to my high school days and the discovery in my junior year of the wonder that was Gone with the Wind. Imagine my delight when I discovered that there was a sequel floating around out there authorized by Margaret Mitchell's estate. Then I read it. The whole thing was just off. I kept thinking throughout the entire book that Scarlett would NOT act/think/feel that way and the loss of character integrity ruined the whole book for me.



In high school I also read The Mists of Avalon by Marion Zimmer Bradley which I LOVED. I immediately picked up Lady of Avalon which was written with Diana L. Paxson and really enjoyed this one too. A couple of years ago, remembering how much I enjoyed the previous books I had read in this series I picked up Priestess of Avalon. It was not even close to being on the same level as the previously mentioned books. Again, it got me thinking if this was because Lady was written before Bradley's death and Priestess was after.



Now being the neurotic reader that I am, I try to collect as many in a series as I can before I start reading the series. Among the other series on my shelves waiting to be read:

The Dragonriders of Pern series which started with Anne McCaffrey and are now mostly being written by her son Todd.....



and the Wheel of Time Series by Robert Jordan which is now being written by Brandon Sanderson.



When I finally do get around to reading these, will the later novels written by new authors be on the same level as the works by the original author? I hate to judge all series by my experiences with the few I've come upon in this scenario, but I'm curious-what other series have you run across that have switched authors mid-series and do you find that those novels are of the same quality as the older ones in the series?

I can't imagine how difficult it must be for an author to jump on board and write a novel in a series that was not their brainchild, their baby, their ah ha moment that kept them awake at night building the world in which their characters would live. If I were in that situation I think I would go mad with worry that I would somehow not please the fans of the earlier books. I cannot help but feel that in some instances the series should have been done when the original author passed on or decided not to write it anymore. Thoughts?

Monday, January 24, 2011

Mailbox Monday-Best Mailbox EVER!

 Mailbox Monday was created by Marcia at The Printed Page. It is currently on tour and this month is being hosted by Rose City Reader.

I had a wee bit o' Christmas money left and I am starting a biggest book loser challenge on February 1st so I had to do a little shopping and get in my last hurrah before I'm not allowing myself to buy books anymore. Well, I ended up with some awesome reads to keep me busy til the end of the year when the challenge is over and I can go nuts and buy a trillion books :)

From PBS:
  • Maid Marian by Elsa Watson


From Barnes & Noble:
  • Within the Hollow Crown by Margaret Campbell Barnes
  • The Winter Sea by Susanna Kearsley
  • Victory of Eagles (Temeraire Bk 5) by Naomi Novik
  • The Edge of the World by Kevin J. Anderson
  • Desiree by Annemarie Selinko
  • The Queen of Last Hopes by Susan Higginbotham


Ordered online from Alibris:
  • The Winter Mantle by Elizabeth Chadwick
  • The Wild Hunt by Elizabeth Chadwick
  • Shields of Pride by Elizabeth Chadwick
  • The Running Vixen by Elizabeth Chadwick
  • The Scarlet Cloak by Jean Plaidy
  • Shadows and Strongholds by Elizabeth Chadwick
  • A Place Beyond Courage by Elizabeth Chadwick


Now I know how Charlie Bucket felt when he found the golden ticket!

Happy reading all!

Sunday, January 23, 2011

Suddenly Sunday

Sunday Sunday is hosted by Svea at A Muse in the Fog. I am kind of bummed the weekend is going by so fast but I am looking forward to a nice lazy Sunday. I can think of nothing better to do as we have at least 18 inches of snow outside and icicles that reach from my roof to a foot shy of the ground. No way am I going out in that!

This week I posted 4 Reviews:
The first 4 entries for the Chivalrous Deeds Challenge have been entered. I've already went to B&N and grabbed one of these because it sounded so good. Check them out here.

Earlier this week I started The White Mare by Jules Watson but I could not get into it right away because I've read so many recently in the same time period. I am taking a break from that to travel to 13th c Wales with Sharon Kay Penman's Here be Dragons. Hopefully I will finish and post reviews on both of those this week.

Hope everyone enjoys the rest of their Sunday!

Friday, January 21, 2011

REVIEW: Alexander and Alestria by Shan Sa

From Amazon: "Beginning with Alexander's childhood in Macedonia with his abusive father, tyrannical King Philip and his overbearing mother Olympias - educated by Aristotle and trained in the military training - he develops the fierce character, strength, and ambition to overthrow his abusive father and take the crown. Meanwhile, in the wilds of the Siberian steppe, Alestria is queen of the Amazons - the tribe of female warriors who dominate this vast land at the edge of the known world. Switching between the distinct voices of Alexander, Alestria, and Tania (the queen's loyal follower and confidante), Shan Sa brings the reader to the center of harsh physical and emotional battles. After Alexander conquers and unifies all of ancient Greece and Egypt and sets out to the Orient to conquer his rival, King Darius of Persia, Alexander and Alestria first encounter each other on the battlefield; surprised to find that his adversary is a woman, Alexander is instantly smitten: her hair is long and black, her body muscular and bronzed, and her skin scarred from years of battle. And at last, this independent woman who had renounced men has found a reason to leave her tribe."

This book seeks to tell the story of Alexander, one of the greatest Generals of his time. He conquered all of THIS, most of it by the age of 30. In this version, we meet Alexander as a little boy-a very effeminate one (his mother dresses him and braids his long hair like a little girl). When Alexander grows into a beautiful young man through his warrior training, his father King Philip takes notice and (well there is no other way to say it) has a sexual relationship with his son. He also shares Alexander with his friends. Alexander uses this as a means of manipulating his father. YES-this book really went there and that is just the beginning. When Philip is assassignated Alexander (who by now has had many lovers including Hephaestion, his best friend) takes his Army off to conquer Persia.

Meanwhile-far off in Asia lives Alestria, young Queen of the Amazons. She leads her band of women warriors, a tribe which follows her faithfully. One day she encounters a warrior and they do battle. She is shocked to learn he is a man and despite rule numero uno of being an Amazon Queen-do not fall in love with a man-she falls for Alexander and leaves the tribe to be his bride. She is followed by the faithful Tania who refuses to abandon her Queen even though she has abandoned the Amazons. What follows is Alexander and Alestria's intense love affair. They make passionate love, he runs off to conquer more territory, the once fierce Queen is lonely, he comes back, lather, rinse, repeat. We go from this once proud, fierce Queen to a love sick ball of misery pining away for Alexander.

The narrative switches between Alexander, Alestria and Tania and on several occasions the transition between who was narrating was confusing. It often took me a few pages to realize whose point of view we were seeing now. Adding to the confusion, the author refers to Alexander part time as Alestries so we have Alestries and Alestria. Also when the Amazons are part of the tribe they have a "T" in front of their names to indicate this so for half the book we have Talestria and Tania and for the other half we have Alestria and Ania. Really confusing.

The biggest flaw in the book by far were the historical inaccuracies. I will list them here. Since many are spoilers please scroll over the area between the asterisks to see them. If you choose not to see the spoilers then just know the ending is not believable at all (in fact it is quite ridiculous). The only saving grace to this whole book is that it reads like poetry. The language is beautiful. Unfortunately, the story that unfolds using that beautiful language is just not good at all. Bottom line-this would have earned a C'est Terrible! rating had it not been for the language. Find yourself another Alexander book.

*
>Issue #1: the already aforementioned portrayal of Alexander as a girl child who was cruelly used by his father and cohorts.

>Never heard of Alestria in Alexander's history? That is because the author tries to say that when Alexander takes her for his bride he gives her the name Roxana. Alexander was indeed married to Roxana but Roxana was a Bactrian noblewoman NOT an Amazon Queen.

>In this version, Alexander is finally felled by an arrow to the forehead from the forces of Poros, a powerful Indian king. Alexander survives but is left handicapped both mentally and physically. Alestria continues to love him despite his infirmity. He hands his great Kingdom over to Haphaestion, installs look alikes for himself and Alestria on the throne and goes tra la la-ing back to Amazon country with Alestria to live the rest of his days. The book says they enjoyed 36 years together. What really happened you ask? Hephaestion died of a fever a year before Alexander so there is no way Alexander could have left his Kingdom in Hephaestion's charge. He would have been dead at this point. Alexander was married not once but three times. Roxana was his first wife. In this story those other two wives never happened. Alexander died of an illness (some say poisoning) just before his 33rd birthday not taking in the scenery on the steppes of Asia with his Amazon Queen*


From my own personal library

Thursday, January 20, 2011

REVIEW: The Memoirs of Helen of Troy by Amanda Elyot

Helen of Troy has been described as the most beautiful woman in the world, the face that launched a thousand ships. When we first meet Helen here, she laments the fact that of 10 children she has one remaining, Hermione, the daughter who has no love for her long absent mother. Helen begins to recount her life in the hopes that her tale will reach her estranged daughter and make her see why Helen made the choices she did.

Helen recounts her girlhood as a Spartan Princess. Daughter of Queen Leda, she has long been rumored to be the offspring of Zeus, not Tyndareus who rules the kingdom at her mother's side. Helen is ostracized by the other girls for her beauty and is cruelly treated by her jealous sister Clytemnestra. Helen grows into an even more beautiful teenager. One day while she is out with her best friend, she is kidnapped by Theseus who teaches her how to use her beauty to rule all those around her. When she is finally returned to Sparta, Tyndareus decides it is time for her to marry and gives her to Menelaus, a man ruled by his brother Agamemnon and whose jealousy drives Helen away. While visiting the Spartan court, Prince Paris Alexandros of Troy catches Helen's eye. They fall in love and she departs Sparta with him. Agamemnon uses this as the excuse he needed to bring down Troy and sets off after her with Menelaus and the Spartan allies, starting a bloody war that will last 10 years. At the Troyan court Helen is just as much an outcast as she was in her girlhood. She details her life during the ten years of the war, Troy's defeat and her return to Sparta.

I really liked this version of Helen's story. Told in her own words, Elyot does not seek to make Helen a perfect person. She is flawed and as we learn, makes some very bad decisions throughout her lifetime. The author does a wonderful job at making Helen seem like a real person (even though she is not entirely mortal). She suffers because of many of her choices, most notably the loss of her first love, and the decision to leave her children behind to follow Paris back to Troy. I thought her rivalry with her sister Clytemnestra and the contrast between the two sisters was well written and I liked the fact that the author gave a plausible reason for the war besides fighting over Helen.

The love between Helen and Paris which is the center point of the story was a little bit troublesome because it felt like even though this was her love of a lifetime all the focus was on the physical relationship. I know, she's the most beautiful woman to ever live but wasn't there anything at all beyond that for Paris (or anyone else) to admire? I also had a hard time with her decision to leave her children. It felt like not enough attention was given to such an agonizing decision (and one I could never see myself making). The pacing of the story seemed a little off to me at times too. Helen would go into great detail about one aspect of her life but other areas would be glossed over. For instance, much was written on her time with Theseus but later in the book when she was at Troy it was like boom! "Paris and I now have three children".

Despite those few areas of concern, enjoyed this sympathetic look at Helen's life. I will be reading Helen of Troy by Margaret George later this year and will be interested to see how it stacks up to this story.

Check out this site I ran across which features several pieces of fine art depicting Helen, the main players in the myth, and the Fall of Troy.


From my own personal library

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

REVIEW: The Long Song by Andrea Levy

At the behest of her son, an old woman sits down to write the story of her life. That woman is July, a former slave at the Amity Plantation in Jamaica. The product of rape, July lives on the plantation with her mother Kitty working at lesser strenuous jobs in the field as other children did. One day she comes to the notice of Caroline Mortimer, sister of the plantation owner and Caroline decides to bring July to the main house as her servant, renaming her Marguerite as she thinks it sounds more pleasant. July grows up in this environment observing the brutalities committed at the Plantation. The Jamaican slaves revolt and life on the plantation is thrown into chaos.

July and the rest of the slaves are freed but she still feels compelled to stay and serve Caroline Mortimer who teaches her to read and write in order to help her run the plantation. It looks as though things might be different for the now freed slaves when the ideological Robert Goodwin arrives to be overseer. He falls in love with July and marries Caroline Mortimer so that he may carry on with July without sinning (his father who is a preacher told him it is a sin to take advantage of slaves but married men may do as they like). As Robert struggles with the slaves he soon changes throwing the plantation into chaos and deceiving July in the worst way possible.

Told in the straight forward voice of July (in some cases too forward for her son's liking) the story of her life and the injustices of the Amity Plantation pour forward. The slaves here are treated appallingly, the overseers are given free reign to do whatever they will with the slaves (rape, beatings, selling food meant for the slaves so they are close to starving). Even when July graduates to the Great House her life is not easy as she has to put up with whiny, needy, overindulged Miss Caroline. July thinks she's finally found the silver lining in her circumstances with her love for Robert but even that doesn't turn out as expected.

This is a sad tale and a solid chronicle of life as a slave on the Jamaican sugar plantations. I liked the feisty July and her manner of telling the story. Her disagreements with her son about how she should write her story were comical at times. I liked this story but it did not captivate me the way that other stories on similar topics did. It reminded me a bit of the Kitchen House by Kathleen Grissom which I read last year and loved. I just didn't like this one as much. I think the transition of Robert from the loving man July first meets to the disillusioned and cruel plantation master he becomes could have been more gradual. It seemed like a Jekyll/Hyde type deal to me where one chapter he's loving and admirable and the next he's horrible. I also thought the book would have dealt more with the slave revolt than it did. It was more in the background than I thought it would be.

I think the book was enjoyable enough and I may try more by this author. I just think I may have read too many books in the same vein for it really pull me in (Kitchen House, Someone Knows my Name by Lawrence Hill, The Soul Catcher by Michael C. White etc).


borrowed from the Fruitport Library

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

REVIEW: Fall of Giants by Ken Follett

Wales June 22, 1911: 13 year old Billy Williams prepares to go down into the mines for the first time to help his family bring in money to alleviate their poverty.

January 1914: The Earl Fitzherbert, 9th richest man in Britian, his wife Russian Princess Bea, and his sister Maud sit down to a dinner party and discuss the possibilities of war between England and Germany with guests American Gus Dewar, and German Walter von Ulrich.

February 1914: American Gus Dewar, aide to President Woodrow Wilson, accompanies a party to Russia to tour their factories and gauge the political climate due the upheaval caused by the growing anger of the Russian population living under the Tsar's brutal regime. There he meets Grigori and Lev Peshkov, men who were orphaned at a young age and are now trying to grind out an existence working at the factory during this turbulent time.

All of these occurrences may seem mundane but they set the stage for the intertwined stories of these 5 families for the next decade. We follow the Williams family of Wales, the Fitzherberts of England, the American Gus Dewar, the German von Ulrich family and the Russian Peshkov brothers through the events that lead up to WW1, through the war, and to what remains of each of their lives at the conclusion of the conflict. Fall of Giants is one monstrous history lesson, clocking in at 985 pages and wrapped in the compelling stories of each of these people. For someone who picked up this novel knowing just the basics of why World War I was fought I felt I learned an incredible amount from this book by being able to see the build up to the war and the war itself from all sides of the issue. In addition to WW1 the book also covers characters dealing with women's suffrage in the UK, the Russian Revolution, and Prohibition. Follett does an incredible job of giving each of these families their own story and managing to tie them all together at different points in the story.

If you're looking for a book full of action or a specific plot, perhaps you should steer clear of this book. The best way I can describe how it reads is if you were walking into the lives of these five families at different times observing what was going on. The plot is the war itself and how it impacts each of the characters. If you are looking for a well researched snapshot of this period of time in the world, this is the book for you and I hope you enjoy it as much as I did.


borrowed from the Fruitport Library